The Top 5 (4) Ice Cream/Gelato/Sorbet

Strawberry Ice Cream in Paris

Strawberry Ice Cream in Paris

A month or so ago, the biggest food critic in my life visited me in NYC; my mother. I took her to Mario Batali’s Otto for dinner, but my main motif was to have her try the olive oil gelato. She called me a couple days later and said, “Andrew… I can’t stop thinking about that olive oil gelato- it was fabulous.”  


Thank you all for sharing your childhood (and grown-up) ice cream favorites!


My Top 4 in no particular order:


Ice Cream:  Olive Oil Gelato

Location:  Otto

City:  NYC, NY

Testimonial:  This insanely flavored gelato is almost perfect, sprinkled with sea salt.”


Ice Cream:  Corn Ice Cream

Location:  Cones

City:  NYC. NY

Testimonial:  This Argentine-style ice cream (resembles gelato) is made with sweet corn. Sound gross? It’s crazy good.”


Ice Cream:  Strawberry Shortcake

Location:  Baskin-Robbins

City:  Deerfield, IL (multiple locations)

Testimonial:  How can I not include this? It’s a childhood favorite.”


Ice Cream:  Strawberry Ice Cream

Location:  Bertillon

City:  Isle St. Louis- Paris, France

Testimonial:  – Recommended by too many people when I traveled to Paris, I about stopped in my own tracks on a street corner to eat it because I could not do two things at once. “



THE TOP 5’s:


1.)  Ice Cream:  Chocolate and Coconut

Location:  Bacio Gelato

City:  Coconut Grove, FL

Testimonial:  “… hands down.”


2.)  Ice Cream:  Coffee Vanilla Swirl

Location:  Pinkberry

City:  L.A. (multiple locations)

Testimonial:  “with coconut on top of course”


3.)  Ice Cream:  A play on Banana Split

Location:  An underground dining group

City:  Chicago, IL

Testimonial:  “It had dark chocolate-habanero ice cream, so it was sweet, bitter, freezing cold and intensely spicy all the same time. There were caramelized manzano bananas, peanut brittle, and warm meaty bacon lardons as the garnish. Absolutely unreal. With my top button undone, I swore I wasn’t going to make it through dessert, but when this came out I was licking the bowl.”


4.)  Ice Cream:  Nutella Ice Cream

Location:  Amorino

City:  Paris, France



5.)  Ice Cream:  Moose Tracks

Location:  Sherman’s Dairy

City:  South Haven, MI

Testimonial:  “It’s worth the wait, which there always is, all summer long!”


6.)  Ice Cream:  Breyer’s Heavenly Hash Ice Cream

Location:  (Select Grocery Store)

City:  (see above)

Testimonial:  “It’s vanilla and chocolate ice cream filled with white vanilla marshmallow swirls, chopped almonds, and dark chocolate chunks.  When allowed to soften just a bit it becomes almost sublime.”


7.)  Ice Cream:  Caramel Buerre Salee (Salted Butter Caramel) with Pear Sorbet

Location:  Berthillon

City:  Paris, France

Testimonial:  “The two flavors in one cup taste like a caramelized pear tart.”


8.)  Ice Cream:  Salted Butter Caramel OR Roasted Banana

Location:  Bi-Rite Creamery

City:  San Francisco, CA

Testimonial:  “Salted Butter Caramel is quite tasty and a good stop if you can’t get to Paris. You can feel the high-fat content of the ice cream in your mouth.”  


9.)  Ice Cream:  (Any Flavor)

Location:  Cows

City:  Park City, Utah

Testimonial:  “This Canadian ice cream maker has a shop in Park City.  16% butterfat content! Any flavor will do.”


10.)  Ice Cream:  Death by Chocolate

Location:  3B’s

City:  Harrisburg, PA

Testimonial:  “It’s an old fashioned shop with great homemade ice creams – I’ve never tasted an ice cream there I didn’t like.”


11.)  Ice Cream:  Prailine’s and Cream

Location:  Baskin-Robbins

City:  (multiple locations)

Testimonial:  “There are real prailines in the cream. Candy covered nuts. Seriously delicious.”


12.)  Ice Cream:  Popcorn Ice Cream Sundae

Location:  Country Restaurant

City:  NYC, NY

Testimonial:  “You think Otto has got salty and sweet down? This is kettle corn in a melty dish.”


13.)  Ice Cream:  Wattleseed, Naga AND Pandan Ice Cream

Location:  Vosges Chocolates

City:  NYC, NY (other locations)



14.)  Ice Cream:  Saffron Gelato

Location:  Azucar

City:  Chicago, IL

Testimonial:  “It’s sweet and savory and unbelievable.”


15.)  Ice Cream:  Pera & Pecorino (pear and pecorino cheese)

Location:  (on it’s way)

City:  Lucca, Italy

Testimonial:  “WOW!!! I can’t stop thinking about that!!!”


16.)  Ice Cream:  Key Lime Pie Ice Cream

Location:  Kilwin’s

City:  Ft. Lauderdale, FL

Testimonial:  “key lime ice cream, with chocolate covered graham cracker pieces and a swirl of cream cheese.”


17.)  Ice Cream:  Sweet Cream Ice Cream

Location:  Farfars

City:  Duxbury, MA

Testimonial:  “There flavors are great but the sweet cream which is the base of most of the specialty flavors is just divine!”


18.)  Ice Cream:  Helado de Chocolate

Location:  Heladeria Rayas

City:  Sevilla, Spain

Testimonial:  “No better place to wash down a few litros of Estrella del Sur and take in the Spanish nightlife”


19.)  Ice Cream:  Ice Cream Sundae

Location:  McDonald’s

City:  Deerfield, IL  (multiple locations)

Testimonial:  “$1 Ice Cream Sunday – Can you possibly beat this deal?  Extra nuts.”


20.)  Ice Cream:  Chocolate Cookie Sandwich

Location:  Toll House

City:  (grocery store)

Testimonial:  “Everyone knows about this one but never disappoints.”


21.)  Ice Cream:  Maine Maple Walnut

Location:  Quiet Side Café & Ice Cream Shop

City:  Southwest Harbor, ME

Testimonial:  “Sometimes the journey to The Perfect Ice Cream Cone is part of the flavor…. My personal favorite is the Maine Maple Walnut. That sweet maple and cream blends perfectly with that slightly bitter taste that walnuts have. Sometimes they will even throw a little banana in there (after all, it’s homemade!). But you’ll be torn between all the soft serve and hard serve flavors and whether to get vanilla to go a la mode over one of their incredible blueberry pies.


22.)  Ice Cream:  Strawberry

Location:  Jordan Pond House

City:  Bar Harbor, ME

Testimonial:  “it’s a little more fancy-pants, but the homemade strawberry ice
cream at the Jordan Pond House in the main section of the park actually does strawberries (my favorite fruit) justice!”


23.)  Ice Cream:  Strawberry Shortcake Ice Cream Bars

Location:  Good Humor

City: (truck or grocery store)



24.)  Ice Cream:  (any flavor)

Location:  Marino’s Italian Ice




25.)  Ice Cream:  Ice Cream Sandwiches

Location:  (grocery store)

City:  (see above)

Testimonial:  “the shitty ones”


26.)  Ice Cream:  Mint Chocolate Chip Ice Cream

Location:  Baskin-Robbins

City:  (multiple locations)

Testimonial:  “-I don’t care that its artificially colored, its the smashed chips that make it memorable.”


27.)  Ice Cream:  Peppermint Chocolate Chip

Location:  Otto

City:  NYC, NY

Testimonial:  “early summer season- NON artificially colored– the real deal. They have it now…”


28.)  Ice Cream: 

Location:  Freddy’s Pizza and Gelateria

City:  Cicero, IL

Testimonial:  “… the gelato is amazing.  Great choice of flavors!  My mom and I stop there whenever we are anywhere near Cicero, and you know how often that is.  Not often enough though for this food.  Everything is great!”


29.)  Ice Cream: Turtle Banana Split

Location:  Margie’s Candies

City:  Chicago, IL

Testimonial:  Three scoops of ice cream w/ hot caramel on top, a split banana, whipcream, cherry, nuts and their famous hotfudge on the side w/ a vanilla wafer. This place is a dessert lovers dream…their hotfudge is like candy crack! The menu is huge and filled w/ all kinds of delicious desserts. I could go on for ever but instead I’m going to call them right now and tell them how great they truly are!”


30.)  Ice Cream:  Snickers Blizzard

Location:  Dairy Queen

City:  Carbondale, IL (multiple locations)

Testimonial:  “An all time favorite that will probably never leave my life.”


31.)  Ice Cream:  Cannoli Ice Cream

Location:  Gelloti’s

City:  West Patterson, NJ

Testimonial:  “it’s technically italian ice, but its creamy so I’m making the bold statement of saying it could hold its own in this category- perfect blend of ice and cream, authentic enough to feel like you’re eating it out of a shell from the old country.”


32.)  Ice Cream:  Cherry Garden Chip

Location:  Jaxson’s Ice Cream Parlor

City:  Dania Beach, FL



33.)  Ice Cream:  Brownie Nut

Location:  Ron’s Gourmet

City:  Hyde Park, MA



34.)  Ice Cream:  Coconut Chip & Blackberry Chip

Location:  Graeter’s

City:  Columbus, OH



35.)  Ice Cream:  Strawberry

Location:  Crème Cremaillere Restaurant

City:  Bedford, NY



36.)  Ice Cream:  Dutch Chocolate & Blueberry

Location:  Fosselman’s

City:  Alhambra, CA



37.)  Ice Cream:  Cherry Moobilee 

Location:  Moomers

City:  Traverse City, MI

Testimonial:  “Choc pieces, cherries, brownies, MMM !!!”


38.)  Ice Cream:  Lemon/Raspberry/Watermelon/Orange

Location:  Vivolo in Firenze

City:  Florence

Testimonial:  “Enough said, it is the holy grail of gelato…and they too have bizarre flavors.”


39.)  Ice Cream:  Nocciole/Limone/Stracciatella

Location:  Gelatiamo

City:  Seattle, WA

Testimonial:  “Nocciole, Limone and Stracciatella are the mark of a good gelato…Maria’s stuff is great and it is classical!


40.)  Ice Cream:  Oatmeal Cookie Chunk

Location:  Ben & Jerry’s

City:  (grocery store)

Testimonial:  “I love A LOT of ice cream flavors but I could only eat one for the rest of my life it would be Ben & Jerry’s Oatmeal Cookie Chunk. It’s AMAZING!… It is VERY easy to finish an entire carton in one sitting because you can’t put it down. It’s hard to find, but when you do, I suggest you stock up!”


41.)  Ice Cream:  Mocha Chocolate Chip

Location:  Graeter’s

City:  Columbus, OH

Testimonial:  “Hands down best ice cream experience… I’ve never actually made it to one of their retail locations, but I have anxiously awaited the overnight delivery guy’s knock on the door the morning following my phone order. This French pot style ice cream is as rich and flavorful as any I’ve had in the USA. The coffee flavor rivals the fullness of my daily morning brew and then to call it “chips” is not even close to being accurate. The chocolate is ladled into the cold cream, forming thick veins of hardened dark sweetness throughout. At our kitchen counter, which is about as far as the pint containers get in our home, the lucky guy (or gal) who strikes the vein gets to follow it as far as it reaches…then the container gets passed to the next prospector.  Sometimes I cheat.”


42.)  Ice Cream:  Riso Gelato

Location:  Festival di Gelato

City:  Florence, Italy

Testimonial:  “… an all time favorite European gelato… This frozen rice pudding gelato is memorable, could cause you to cash in frequent traveler mileage,  and is an absolute must for aficionados eating their way through Tuscany.”


43.)  Ice Cream:  Mango Ice Cream Bar

Location:  Mexican Pushcarts

City:  Chicago, IL

Testimonial:  “I love the ice cram bar covered with mango on the outside- no not just the mango ice- the crema ones.”


44.)  Ice Cream:  Salty Caramel Ice Cream

Location:  Bi Rite Creamery

City:  San Francisco, CA

Testimonial:  “Maybe my favorite flavor ever. Perfect balance of sweet and salty.”


45.)  Ice Cream:  Mont Avalanche Ice Cream

Location:  The Chocolate Shoppe

City:  Madison, WI

Testimonial:  “Mint ice cream (all of the ice creams are made in the science lab at UW – Madison), oreo cookies, andes candies and fudge swirl. Very heady.”


46.)  Ice Cream:  Coconut Gelato

Location:  Vivoli

City:  Florence, Italy

Testimonial:  “When I was in Italy it was my mission to taste every coconut gelato there was. This place had the best…”


47.)  Ice Cream:  Olive Oil Gelato

Location:  Sociale

City: San Francisco, CA

Testimonial:  “We actually had vanilla gelato with olive oil and salt. Either way I had no idea how tasty that combo was. Genius.”


48.)  Ice Cream:  Buko or Ube Ice Cream 

Location:  Mitchell’s

City:  San Francisco, CA

Testimonial:  “Buko I guess is a baby coconut and ube is a purple yam both found in the Philippines. The Buko is great if you love coconut because it has the same flavor, but the coconut bits are soft. Ube is delicious also and really is just purple ice cream that tastes like sweet cream. Both are super delicious.”


49.)  Ice Cream:  Vanilla Soft Serve Ice Cream 

Location:  Tony’s Sub’s


Testimonial:  “home of the Warriors… In a safety cone- Hot summer day, cool summer treat, taste explosion….can’t tell it is Low Cal also.”


50.)  Ice Cream:  Ice Cream Sandwich

Location:  Diddy Reese

City:  Westwood, CA

Testimonial:  “I like the cookie dough ice cream with a chocolate cookie…”


51.)  Ice Cream:  Chocolate Soft Serve Ice Cream

Location:  Dairy Queen

City:  Northbrook, IL  (multiple locations)



52.)  Ice Cream:  Vanilla Cone with chocolate jimmies

Location:  Mister Softee

City:  NYC, NY  (multiple locations)



53.)  Ice Cream:  Gold Medal Ribbon

Location:  Baskin-Robbins

City:  Philly, PA  (multiple locations)

Testimonial:  “The perfect balance of vanilla and chocolate with just a little swirl of caramel.  Add some chocolate jimmies on top… perfection.” 


54.)  Ice Cream:  Lemon Custard

Location:  Jarling’s Custard Cup

City:  Champaign, IL

Testimonial:  “The Lemon Custard is the perfect cool treat on a hot summer day in good old C-U.” 


55.)  Ice Cream:  Rainbow Cone

Location:  Walt’s

City:  Joliet, IL

Testimonial:  “Famous for it’s towering Rainbow Cone, always a challenge to eat it all before it drips down onto your shoes!!  A tradition in Joliet, it is so old school, I can’t even find the phone number for it!!!!” 


56.)  Ice Cream:  Kitchen Sink

Location:  Jaxson’s Ice Cream Parlor

City:  Dania Beach, FL

Testimonial:  “… literally served in a miniature kitchen sink and loaded with whatever ice cream flavors the scooper feels like. It’s a huge serving so bring friends but its damn worth it. The ice cream is homemade and the best I’ve ever had.”



57.)  Ice Cream:  Butter Pecan

Location:  Fair Oaks Dairy

City:  Fair Oaks, IN



58.)  Ice Cream:  Strawberries in Vanilla Gelato

Location:  (little place off the square)

City:  Rome, Italy



59.)  Ice Cream:  Vanilla and Butter Pecan

Location:  Graeter’s Ice Cream

City:  Columbus, OH



60.)  Ice Cream:  Vanilla Ice Cream

Location:  Table 52

City:  Chicago, IL

Testimonial:  “… with the Hummingbird cake…”


61.)  Ice Cream:  Vanilla Ice Cream Cone dipped in chocolate coating

Location:  Dairy Queen

City:  (multiple locations)

Testimonial:  On a hot day- dipped in chocolate coating- it’s not real but who cares- it brings back memories of childhood in the south.” 


62.)  Ice Cream:  Pumpkin (seasonal)

Location:  Krisch’s

City:  Massapequa, NY



63.)  Ice Cream:  Fiordilatte Gelato

Location:  Grom Gelateria

City:  Florence, Italy (and now in NYC)

Testimonial:  “Essence of milk” is what comes to mind when eating this smooth,
rich, creamy and clean flavor.”







Ice Cream:  Chocolate Milkshake

Location:  Cherry Pit Cafe

City:  Deerfield, IL

Testimonial:  “That chocolate milkshake served in the metal mixing cup is one of my fondest childhood memories.”


Ice Cream:  Ice Cream bar

Location:  Lindemans

City:  Deerfield, IL

Testimonial:  “… enough said. Everything there taste better if you leave your rollerblades on!”


Ice Cream:  Chocolate Soft Serve

Location:  TCBY

City:  Highland Park, IL

Testimonial:  “… the old TCBY by the new Judy’s…”


1 Comment

Filed under Uncategorized

One response to “The Top 5 (4) Ice Cream/Gelato/Sorbet

  1. I constantly spent my half an hour to read this website’s articcles everyday along with a cup of coffee.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s